What are the relative contributions of canonical JAK-STAT3 versus non-canonical MEK-ERK IL-11 signalling, alone or in combination, to the ageing phenotypes reversed by IL-11 inhibition?
KNOWLEDGE GAP
OPEN
knowledge_gap_il11_canonical_versus_noncanonical_ageing
Attached to:
IL-11 Receptor Signalling Activation
ERK-AMPK-mTORC1 Axis Dysregulation
IL-11 receptor engagement bifurcates into canonical STAT3 and non-canonical ERK-p90RSK arms, and both feed the ERK-AMPK-mTORC1 axis. Which arm dominates for a given ageing phenotype is unresolved, and it matters for drug design: a STAT3-dominant phenotype might be addressable with existing JAK-STAT inhibitors, whereas an ERK-dominant phenotype argues for ligand/receptor neutralization or MEK inhibition. Curators should keep the two arms separated on the amplifier node rather than asserting either as the settled effector.
Does the healthspan and lifespan extension achieved by IL-11 inhibition in aged mice translate to human ageing, or is the survival benefit specific to the laboratory-mouse ageing model?
HUMAN MODEL MISMATCH
OPEN
human_model_mismatch_il11_lifespan_extension
Attached to:
Frailty, Multimorbidity and Reduced Lifespan
The organismal-outcome node - reduced frailty, multimorbidity, age-related cancer and >20% median lifespan extension - rests entirely on mouse genetics (Il11 / Il11ra1 deletion) and anti-IL-11 antibody dosing from 75 weeks of age; there is no human survival or frailty evidence. This is a HUMAN_MODEL_MISMATCH rather than a plain KNOWLEDGE_GAP because the effect IS demonstrated in a model system and it is the translational validity to human ageing that is open. It is mechanistically meaningful because mouse late-life mortality is heavily cancer-driven (the autopsy tumour-burden data), whereas human ageing mortality is dominated by cardiovascular, neurodegenerative and multi-morbid disease, so a lifespan benefit routed largely through reduced murine tumours need not reproduce in humans. Anti-IL-11 is already in early-stage human trials for fibro-inflammatory disease, which is the natural setting to begin resolving this - but until human ageing endpoints exist, conforming disorder entries should not inherit the lifespan-extension claim.
Proposed experiments:
Human ageing and frailty endpoints in an anti-IL-11 clinical cohort