Borrelia Miyamotoi Disease (BMD): Comprehensive Disease Characterization Report

Target disease: Borrelia Miyamotoi Disease (Hard-tick relapsing fever) MONDO ID: MONDO:0958150 | Category: Infectious Disease (tick-borne, zoonotic bacterial) Report basis: 5 investigative iterations, 9 confirmed findings, 35 papers reviewed. Evidence types: human clinical, model organism, in-vitro/genomic. Date: 2026-09-29.


Summary

Borrelia miyamotoi disease (BMD) is an emerging, hard-tick–transmitted relapsing fever caused by the spirochete Borrelia miyamotoi. Unlike the classical soft-tick relapsing fever borreliae, B. miyamotoi is transmitted by hard-bodied Ixodes ticks — the same ticks that transmit Lyme disease (B. burgdorferi), human granulocytic anaplasmosis (Anaplasma phagocytophilum), and babesiosis (Babesia microti). The organism was discovered in Ixodes persulcatus in 1994, and the first human disease was described in Russia in 2011. It now has a documented northern-hemisphere distribution spanning Asia, Europe, and North America.

Clinically, BMD is an acute, non-specific febrile illness: high fever, chills, marked headache, and myalgia/arthralgia, frequently accompanied by the laboratory triad of thrombocytopenia, neutropenia, and elevated transaminases. A minority of untreated patients (~10%) manifest the relapsing (recurrent) fever course that gives the relapsing-fever group its name. Severe disease — chiefly meningoencephalitis/meningitis — occurs almost exclusively in immunocompromised patients, particularly those on B-cell–depleting therapy (e.g., rituximab). The pathophysiology rests on a two-tier immune-evasion strategy: (1) innate complement resistance mediated by the Factor H–binding outer-surface protein CbiA, which sustains high-grade spirochetemia, and (2) Vmp antigenic variation by long-segment plasmid gene conversion, which evades adaptive antibody responses and drives relapses. Bacterial clearance ultimately depends on specific antibodies, explaining why antibody-deficient hosts develop severe, persistent, or CNS disease.

Diagnosis relies on acute-phase whole-blood PCR (targets: 16S rRNA, fla/flagellin, glpQ) during spirochetemia, complemented by GlpQ serology — GlpQ (glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase) being an antigen absent from Lyme-group Borrelia, which allows serological discrimination. Because acute seropositivity is low (~16%) while convalescent seroconversion is high (~78%), PCR is the key acute test. Treatment with doxycycline (oral, first-line) is highly effective with excellent prognosis and no chronic sequelae; ceftriaxone is used for CNS disease. There is no genetic etiology, no heritability, and no vaccine; prevention is entirely tick-bite avoidance and prompt tick removal.


Key Findings

F001 — BMD is caused by a hard-tick–transmitted relapsing fever spirochete

Borrelia miyamotoi is phylogenetically a member of the relapsing fever group of spirochetes, distinct from the Lyme borreliosis group (B. burgdorferi sensu lato). It was discovered in Ixodes persulcatus in 1994, and human B. miyamotoi disease was first described in Russia in 2011. Its defining epidemiological anomaly is transmission by hard-bodied Ixodes ticks (I. persulcatus, I. scapularis, I. pacificus, I. ricinus) rather than the soft (argasid) ticks that classically transmit relapsing fever. Small rodents — for example Peromyscus leucopus (the white-footed mouse) — serve as reservoir hosts. Transmission occurs both transovarially (vertically, dam to egg) and horizontally (via blood feeding), and the pathogen is passed transtadially across larval, nymphal, and adult life stages.

"Borrelia miyamotoi is an emerging tick-borne pathogen phylogenetically belonging to spirochaetes causing relapsing fever. It is primarily transmitted by ticks from the Ixodes ricinus complex, similarly to borreliae causing Lyme borreliosis. Small rodents can serve as reservoir hosts." — PMID: 34412488

"B. miyamotoi has a wide distribution since its discovery in Ixodes persulcatus in 1994. The human B. miyamotoi disease was first described in Russia in 2011." — PMID: 33582142

"The pathogen is acquired either transovarially (vertically) or horizontally through blood-feeding and passed transtadially across life stages." — PMID: 35858517

Ontology anchors: NCBI Taxon Borrelia miyamotoi (txid47466); vector Ixodes scapularis (txid6945); reservoir Peromyscus leucopus (txid10041); disease MONDO:0958150.

F002 — BMD presents as an acute febrile illness with relapsing fever and characteristic lab abnormalities

The largest US case series (Molloy et al. 2015; 97 PCR-confirmed cases) established the core clinical picture. Reviewed patients presented with high fever, chills, marked headache, and myalgia or arthralgia; 24% were hospitalized; and elevated liver enzymes, neutropenia, and thrombocytopenia were common laboratory findings. Symptoms resolved with doxycycline and no chronic sequelae were observed. In a Russian inpatient cohort of 79 patients, a recurrent (relapsing) fever course occurred in ~10% (8/79), with affected patients experiencing 2–3 discrete febrile episodes prior to antibiotic treatment.

"Most of the 51 case patients on whom clinical histories were reviewed presented with high fever, chills, marked headache, and myalgia or arthralgia. Twenty-four percent were hospitalized. Elevated liver enzyme levels, neutropenia, and thrombocytopenia were common." — PMID: 26053877

"The recurrent course of the disease was observed in 8 (10%) of the 79 patients. The relapsing fever curve was noted in 6 of the 8 patients; 4 patients had 2 episodes of fever and 2 patients had 3 episodes." — PMID: 26821411

Suggested HPO terms: Fever HP:0001945; Chills HP:0025143; Headache HP:0002315; Myalgia HP:0003326; Arthralgia HP:0002829; Thrombocytopenia HP:0001873; Neutropenia HP:0001875; Elevated hepatic transaminase HP:0002910.

F003 — Antigenic variation via Vmp long-segment plasmid conversion drives relapsing fever

B. miyamotoi carries clusters of gene cassettes encoding variable major proteins (Vmps) on multiple linear plasmids and undergoes antigenic variation in mammalian hosts by switching the expressed vmp cassette. Takeuchi et al. (2025) demonstrated that the switch occurs by replacing the expression cassette and downstream silent cassettes with a long segment (up to 16 kb+) copied from an archival plasmid — a mechanism termed long-segment conversion. Critically, segment conversion was detected by day 5 post-infection, earlier than antibody production, and occurred even in SCID (severe combined immunodeficient) mice, whereas bacterial elimination depended on specific antibodies. This decoupling explains both the relapsing dynamics (new antigenic variants escape existing antibodies) and the vulnerability of antibody-deficient hosts to severe disease.

"Like relapsing fever Borrelia, B. miyamotoi carries clusters of gene cassettes encoding variable major proteins (Vmps) on multiple linear plasmids and shows antigenic variation in mammalian hosts by switching the expression vmp gene cassette." — PMID: 41026790

"while bacterial elimination depended on the presence of specific antibodies, the segment conversion was detected at five days post-infection, earlier than antibody production in mice, and even in severe combined immunodeficient mice." — PMID: 41026790

Suggested GO terms: antigenic variation GO:0020033; evasion of host immune response GO:0042783 / GO:0052572.

F004 — Epidemiology: low tick infection prevalence but measurable human seroprevalence across the northern hemisphere

A systematic review and meta-analysis (Hoornstra et al. 2022) synthesizing 157 studies (165,637 ticks; 45,608 individuals; 504 well-described human cases) found B. miyamotoi prevalence in questing ticks highest in Ixodes persulcatus (2.8%, 95% CI 2.4–3.1) and lowest in I. pacificus (0.7%, 95% CI 0.6–0.8). Overall human seroprevalence was 4.4% (95% CI 2.8–6.3), and slightly higher (~4.6%) in high-risk groups. US surveillance shows B. miyamotoi co-occurs with B. burgdorferi across the Northeast, Upper Midwest, Ohio Valley, and southern Appalachia. Genotypic analyses reveal three distinct geographic populations (North America, Asia, Europe).

"In ticks, the highest prevalence of B miyamotoi was observed in Ixodes persulcatus (2·8%, 95% CI 2·4-3·1) and the lowest in Ixodes pacificus (0·7%, 0·6-0·8). The overall seroprevalence in humans was 4·4% (2·8-6·3)." — PMID: 36113496

"Borrelia miyamotoi belongs to the relapsing fever group of spirochetes and forms distinct populations in North America, Asia, and Europe." — PMID: 31906865

Tick species B. miyamotoi prevalence (questing ticks) Region
Ixodes persulcatus 2.8% (2.4–3.1) Asia / eastern Europe
Ixodes ricinus intermediate Europe
Ixodes scapularis intermediate Eastern/Midwest US
Ixodes pacificus 0.7% (0.6–0.8) Western US

F005 — Diagnosis relies on blood PCR and GlpQ serology; CNS disease occurs in immunocompromised patients

Diagnosis uses whole-blood real-time PCR (targets: 16S rRNA, fla/flagellin, glpQ) during acute spirochetemia, and serology against recombinant glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase (GlpQ) — an antigen absent from Lyme-group Borrelia, enabling serological discrimination from Lyme disease. In the Molloy 2015 series, only 16% of patients were seropositive at presentation, but 78% seroconverted in convalescence, underscoring that acute-phase PCR is the key diagnostic. A multiplexed protein array (Hoornstra 2022) incorporating GlpQ, multiple Vmps, and flagellin improved serodiagnostic accuracy. Meningoencephalitis/meningitis is reported almost exclusively in immunocompromised patients (e.g., those on B-cell–depleting rituximab therapy) and is diagnosed via CSF PCR, sequencing, or Gram stain.

"At presentation, 16% of patients with BMD were seropositive for IgG and/or IgM antibody to B. miyamotoi rGlpQ. Most (78%) had seropositive convalescent specimens." — PMID: 26053877

"Borrelia miyamotoi is an emerging tickborne pathogen that has been associated with central nervous system infections in immunocompromised patients, albeit infrequently." — PMID: 38916722

"The array included six B. miyamotoi antigens: glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase (GlpQ), multiple variable major proteins (Vmps), and flagellin." — PMID: 36314925

Suggested diagnostic anchors: B. miyamotoi DNA by PCR (blood/CSF); anti-GlpQ IgM/IgG serology.

F006 — BMD is effectively treated with doxycycline; CNS disease requires ceftriaxone

In the Molloy 2015 US case series, symptoms resolved after doxycycline treatment with no chronic sequelae. Oral doxycycline is first-line for uncomplicated disease, while parenteral ceftriaxone is used for meningoencephalitis/CNS disease. Early antibiotic treatment appears to prevent relapse and seroconversion: in the Boyer 2020 Alsace study, three patients with isolated IgM were treated with doxycycline, which could have prevented seroconversion. Relapses occurred only in untreated patients — in the Russian cohort, all 8 relapsing patients relapsed before antibiotic treatment.

"Symptoms resolved after treatment with doxycycline, and no chronic sequelae or symptoms were observed." — PMID: 26053877

"Relapses occurred in all the 8 patients before antibiotic treatment." — PMID: 26821411

Suggested NCIT terms: Doxycycline C560; Ceftriaxone C596; Antibiotic Therapy C15844. CHEBI: doxycycline CHEBI:50845; ceftriaxone CHEBI:29007.

F007 — BMD affects all ages including children and co-occurs geographically with other Ixodes-borne pathogens

BMD occurs across the full age spectrum, including young children. Krause et al. (2016) reported hard-tick relapsing fever in a 5-year-old Massachusetts child, PCR-confirmed from an I. scapularis tick removed from the scalp, with seroconversion, fatigue, and recurrent fever. Doxycycline is now acceptable for tick-borne illness in children of any age. Although B. miyamotoi co-occurs geographically with B. burgdorferi across the eastern US, an analysis of 13,437 CDC-tested nymphs (2013–2024) found that B. burgdorferi–B. miyamotoi coinfection did NOT form more often than expected by chance — unlike other Ixodes coinfection pairs — and was the least prevalent of the four studied coinfections. This suggests the two spirochetes' co-occurrence in humans is largely coincidental (shared vector) rather than biologically facilitated.

"A 5-year-old Massachusetts resident developed hard tick-borne relapsing fever caused by Borrelia miyamotoi. A partially engorged Ixodes scapularis tick was removed from her scalp and identified as infected with B. miyamotoi using polymerase chain reaction." — PMID: 27626914

"Except for Bbss-Bmiya, resampling simulations for all coinfections revealed coinfections form more often than expected by chance." — PMID: 41637958

F008 — Innate immune evasion via complement resistance mediated by the Factor H–binding protein CbiA

B. miyamotoi is strongly resistant to complement-mediated bacteriolysis by human serum. It shows reduced surface deposition of C3, C5, C7, C8, C9 and the membrane attack complex (MAC), acting principally at the central component C3 to block C3-convertase formation (Teegler/Wagemakers 2014). Röttgerding et al. (2017) identified CbiA (complement binding and inhibitory protein A), a novel outer-surface Factor H–binding protein that interacts with FH, C3, C3b, C4b, C5, and C9. Factor H bound to CbiA retains cofactor activity for Factor I–mediated C3b inactivation, and CbiA directly inhibits both the classical pathway and terminal complement complex assembly. Ectopic expression of CbiA rendered serum-sensitive B. garinii serum-resistant, and loss of cbiA during in vitro passage increased serum susceptibility — establishing CbiA as a functional determinant. By contrast, the avian relapsing-fever spirochete B. anserina is serum-sensitive, consistent with its lack of human pathogenicity.

"we found that B. miyamotoi showed reduced deposition of components C3, C5, C7, C8, C9 as well as the membrane attack complex (MAC) on the borrelial surface." — PMID: 25104575

"we identified a gene encoding for a putative Factor H-binding protein, termed CbiA (complement binding and inhibitory protein A). Functional analyses revealed that CbiA interacted with complement regulator Factor H (FH), C3, C3b, C4b, C5, and C9." — PMID: 28331202

"we describe that B. miyamotoi is resistant to human complement, which might play an important role in pathogenesis." — PMID: 25189195

Suggested GO terms: complement activation GO:0006956; negative regulation of complement activation GO:0045916; regulation of complement-dependent cytotoxicity GO:1903659.

F009 — Seroprevalence is low in blood donors but markedly elevated in tick-exposed and occupational risk groups

Serosurveys quantify a clear exposure gradient by risk group. In Denmark (n=1180, 2002–2021), seroprevalence was 8.3% in tick-exposed individuals vs 1.5% in blood donors and 3.3% in immunocompromised individuals (p<0.0001; overall 3.1%). In the Netherlands, seroprevalence was 2.0% in blood donors, 10% in forestry workers, and 14.6% in patients with suspected human granulocytic anaplasmosis. In California blood donors (n=1700, western US, I. pacificus zone), only 0.12% were B. miyamotoi-seropositive vs 0.47% for B. burgdorferi, reflecting lower western-US vector infection rates. These figures align with the global meta-analytic seroprevalence of 4.4% (higher, ~4.6%, in high-risk groups).

"Borrelia miyamotoi seroprevalence (being either IgM or IgG positive) among tick-exposed individuals (8.3 %, 95%CI 5.1-13.3) was significantly higher compared to healthy blood donors (1.5 %, 95 % CI 0.8-2.8) and immunocompromised individuals (3.3 %, 95 %CI 1.9-5.5), p < 0.0001." — PMID: 41086691

"The prevalence of anti-B. miyamotoi antibodies among forestry workers was 10% (5.3-16.8%) and in patients with serologically unconfirmed but suspected human granulocytic anaplasmosis was 14.6% (9.0-21.8%); these were significantly higher compared with the seroprevalence in blood donors." — PMID: 25356364

"eight tested positive for antibodies to B. burgdorferi (0.47%, Exact 95% CI: 0.20, 0.93) and two tested positive for antibodies to B. miyamotoi (0.12%." — PMID: 33370341

Population Seroprevalence Country PMID
Blood donors 1.5% Denmark 41086691
Immunocompromised 3.3% Denmark 41086691
Tick-exposed 8.3% Denmark 41086691
Blood donors 2.0% Netherlands 25356364
Forestry workers 10% Netherlands 25356364
Suspected HGA patients 14.6% Netherlands 25356364
Blood donors (western US) 0.12% California, USA 33370341

Section-by-Section Disease Characterization

1. Disease Information

Overview: BMD ("hard-tick relapsing fever") is an emerging zoonotic bacterial infection caused by Borrelia miyamotoi, a relapsing-fever–group spirochete transmitted by Ixodes (hard) ticks. It presents as an acute febrile illness that can relapse and, rarely, cause meningoencephalitis in immunocompromised hosts. Identifiers: MONDO:0958150; MeSH "Borrelia miyamotoi" and "Relapsing Fever"; ICD-11 category 1C1G (relapsing fevers) / ICD-10 A68.- (relapsing fevers). No OMIM entry (non-genetic). Not in Orphanet as a rare Mendelian disease. Synonyms: B. miyamotoi disease; hard-tick relapsing fever (HTRF); Borrelia miyamotoi infection; ixodid tick-borne borreliosis caused by B. miyamotoi (BM-ITBB, Russian literature). Data source type: Aggregated disease-level resources (case series, serosurveys, meta-analyses) plus individual case reports — not EHR-derived at population scale.

2. Etiology

Causal factor: Infectious — the bacterium Borrelia miyamotoi (F001). This is the sole and sufficient cause; the disease is not genetic and has no heritable component. Environmental/behavioral risk factors: Tick exposure is the dominant risk factor — occupational (forestry work), recreational (hiking in endemic areas), and residential proximity to Ixodes habitat (F009). Seasonality follows tick questing activity (late spring–summer). Geographic residence in endemic zones (northeastern/upper-midwestern US, Europe, Russia, Japan, China) increases risk. Host susceptibility factor: Immunocompromise — especially B-cell depletion (rituximab) — is the key modifier of severity, converting a self-limited febrile illness into meningoencephalitis (F003, F005). Genetic risk/protective factors: None identified — there is no human genetic susceptibility locus, GWAS signal, or protective allele known for BMD. Not applicable. Gene–environment interactions: Not applicable in the human host (no host genetic contribution). At the pathogen level, the mammalian-host "environment" drives bacterial genetic switching (Vmp conversion, F003).

3. Phenotypes

Phenotype Type Frequency HPO term
Fever (often high) Symptom Near-universal HP:0001945
Chills Symptom Common HP:0025143
Headache (marked) Symptom Common HP:0002315
Myalgia Symptom Common HP:0003326
Arthralgia Symptom Common HP:0002829
Fatigue Symptom Common HP:0012378
Relapsing/recurrent fever Clinical course ~10% (untreated) HP:0025142 (recurrent fever)
Thrombocytopenia Lab abnormality Common HP:0001873
Neutropenia Lab abnormality Common HP:0001875
Elevated transaminases Lab abnormality Common HP:0002910
Meningoencephalitis / meningitis Clinical sign Rare (immunocompromised) HP:0001287 / HP:0002383

Onset: Adult-predominant but all ages including children (age 5 documented, F007). Severity: Mild-to-moderate in immunocompetent hosts; severe/CNS in immunocompromised. Progression: Self-limited or episodic/relapsing; resolves fully with treatment. QoL impact: Acute illness causes transient functional impairment; no chronic sequelae reported in immunocompetent patients (F006).

4. Genetic/Molecular Information

Not applicable to the human host. BMD has no causal human genes, pathogenic germline/somatic variants, modifier genes, epigenetic changes, or chromosomal abnormalities — it is an infectious disease with no Mendelian or complex-trait genetic architecture. The relevant molecular biology is microbial: B. miyamotoi has a segmented genome with a main linear chromosome and multiple linear/circular plasmids carrying vmp cassettes (F003); the reference isolate Izh-4 genome is characterized (PMID: 31906865). Key pathogen genes/proteins: vmp (variable major proteins, antigenic variation), cbiA (Factor H–binding complement inhibitor), glpQ (glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase — metabolic enzyme and diagnostic antigen), flaB (flagellin), p66 (porin).

5. Environmental Information

Infectious agent: Borrelia miyamotoi (NCBI Taxon 47466), Spirochaetales: Spirochaetaceae, relapsing-fever group (F001). Vectors: Ixodes persulcatus, I. scapularis, I. pacificus, I. ricinus (F001, F004). Reservoirs: small rodents including Peromyscus leucopus (F001). Environmental drivers: tick habitat (deciduous/mixed woodland, leaf litter), climate influencing tick density and questing, and human land use. Lifestyle/occupational factors: outdoor occupation (forestry) and recreation drive exposure (F009). No toxin, radiation, or pollution etiology.

6. Mechanism / Pathophysiology — Ordered Causal Chain

1. Infected Ixodes tick bites human and inoculates B. miyamotoi during blood feeding
      │  (transtadially/transovarially maintained in tick — F001)
      ▼
2. Spirochetes enter dermis and bloodstream → establish spirochetemia
      ▼
3. CbiA (Factor H-binding protein) recruits host Factor H to the spirochete surface
      │  → blocks C3-convertase formation, reduces C3/C5/MAC deposition (F008)
      ▼
4. Complement resistance → spirochetes survive innate serum killing → HIGH-GRADE SPIROCHETEMIA
      ▼
5. High bacterial load → PAMP-driven innate inflammation (fever, chills, myalgia;
      cytopenias: thrombocytopenia, neutropenia; hepatic transaminase elevation) (F002)
      ▼
6. Host mounts specific antibody response against expressed Vmp
      │
      ├─► 7a. Vmp long-segment plasmid conversion (from day 5, antibody-independent,
      │        occurs even in SCID mice) switches surface antigen (F003)
      │            ▼
      │        8a. New antigenic variant escapes existing antibodies → RELAPSE
      │            (recurrent febrile episodes, ~10% untreated — F002/F003)
      │
      └─► 7b. In immunocompetent host: successive antibody waves eventually
               clear all variants → RESOLUTION, no chronic sequelae (F003, F006)

   BRANCH (immunocompromised / B-cell depleted, e.g., rituximab):
      antibody clearance fails → persistent spirochetemia → CNS invasion →
      MENINGOENCEPHALITIS / MENINGITIS (F003, F005)

Upstream vs downstream: The initiating lesions are tick inoculation and CbiA-mediated complement evasion (upstream, innate). Vmp antigenic variation is the mid-stream driver of relapse. Antibody-dependent clearance is the terminal determinant of outcome — its failure (downstream, in immunocompromised hosts) produces severe/CNS disease. Cell types/processes involved: endothelial and blood compartment (spirochetemia); hepatocytes (transaminase elevation); bone marrow/blood cells (cytopenias); complement system components (C3, C5b–C9/MAC); B lymphocytes (CL:0000236) as the critical clearance effector. Metabolic note: GlpQ (glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase) supports phospholipid/glycerol metabolism and doubles as the key serodiagnostic antigen (F005).

7. Anatomical Structures Affected

8. Temporal Development

Onset: Acute, days after an infected tick bite; all ages (pediatric to geriatric). Incubation: on the order of days to ~2 weeks. Course: self-limited in most; relapsing/episodic in ~10% of untreated patients (2–3 febrile episodes; F002). Duration: short (days–weeks) with treatment; no chronic phase in immunocompetent hosts (F006). Critical intervention window: early doxycycline aborts relapse and may prevent seroconversion (F006). Severe branch: in immunocompromised patients, disease may progress to CNS involvement if untreated (F005).

9. Inheritance and Population

Inheritance: None — non-genetic infectious disease (no AD/AR/X-linked/mitochondrial pattern; no penetrance/expressivity/anticipation/founder effects). Epidemiology: Questing-tick prevalence 0.7–2.8% by species; human seroprevalence ~4.4% overall (meta-analysis), with strong risk-group gradients (blood donors ~1.5–2%; forestry ~10%; tick-exposed ~8.3%; western US ~0.12%) (F004, F009). Geographic distribution: northern hemisphere — three distinct populations in North America, Europe, and Asia (F004). Age/sex: all ages affected; no strong sex predilection established. Case-level data derive from aggregated series and serosurveys.

10. Diagnostics

11. Outcome / Prognosis

Excellent prognosis with prompt antibiotic therapy: symptoms resolve and no chronic sequelae are observed in immunocompetent patients (F006). Mortality is very low; deaths are exceptional and generally linked to severe CNS disease in profoundly immunocompromised hosts. Complications: relapse (untreated), meningoencephalitis (immunocompromised). Prognostic factors: immune status (B-cell competence) is the dominant determinant of severity; timeliness of antibiotic treatment governs relapse prevention (F003, F005, F006). No validated prognostic biomarkers beyond spirochetemia and immune status.

12. Treatment

13. Prevention

14. Other Species / Natural Disease

15. Model Organisms


Mechanistic Model / Interpretation

The unifying model of BMD is a two-tier immune-evasion cascade in which the outcome is set by the balance between bacterial evasion and host humoral immunity:

Tier Effector Immune arm evaded Consequence Evidence
Tier 1 (innate) CbiA binds Factor H; blocks C3-convertase, reduces MAC Complement (innate) Survives serum killing → high spirochetemia F008 (P25104575 P28331202 P25189195)
Tier 2 (adaptive) Vmp long-segment plasmid conversion Antibody (adaptive) Antigenic escape → relapse F003 (P41026790)
Resolution / severity switch Specific antibodies clear all variants — Cure (immunocompetent) or CNS disease (immunocompromised) F003, F005, F006

This model explains the full clinical spectrum from a single axis — humoral competence. Immunocompetent hosts eventually generate antibody waves that outpace Vmp switching and clear infection (self-limited, curable, no sequelae). Immunocompromised/B-cell–depleted hosts cannot clear the antigenically shifting population, permitting persistence and CNS invasion. CbiA-mediated complement resistance is the permissive upstream event that allows spirochetemia to reach the levels needed for both symptomatic disease and antigenic-variation–driven relapse.


Evidence Base

PMID Contribution Finding
34412488 Relapsing-fever phylogeny, I. ricinus complex transmission, rodent reservoirs F001
33582142 1994 discovery, 2011 first human disease F001
35858517 Transovarial + horizontal + transtadial transmission F001
26053877 US case series: symptoms, 24% hospitalized, lab triad, doxycycline cure, serology kinetics F002, F005, F006
26821411 Russian cohort: ~10% relapse, pre-treatment relapses F002, F006
41026790 Vmp long-segment conversion; antibody-independent switching, antibody-dependent clearance (SCID) F003
36113496 Meta-analysis: tick prevalence by species, 4.4% human seroprevalence F004
31906865 Reference genome; 3 geographic populations F004
38916722 CNS infection in immunocompromised F005
36314925 Protein array (GlpQ, Vmps, flagellin) F005
27626914 Pediatric case (age 5) F007
41637958 Bbss–Bmiya coinfection at chance frequency only F007
25104575 Reduced C3/C5/MAC deposition (complement resistance) F008
28331202 CbiA identification and function F008
25189195 Human complement resistance; cultivability F008
41086691 Denmark seroprevalence gradient F009
25356364 Netherlands occupational seroprevalence F009
33370341 Low western-US seroprevalence F009
24432595 Differential-diagnosis decision tree (~95% accuracy) Diagnostics

Supporting surveillance literature: Pennsylvania statewide I. scapularis survey (PMID: 38686844), ArboNET DIN trends (PMID: 40907973), German tick-removal study (7.4% of Borrelia-positive ticks were B. miyamotoi; PMID: 31987819), Slovakia (PMID: 35094490), Kazakhstan (PMID: 39332111), Belgium (PMID: 39238018), and NY/Long Island clinical series (PMID: 32473652).


Limitations and Knowledge Gaps

  1. Non-genetic disease: Sections 4 (Genetic/Molecular), 9 (Inheritance), and the genetic-testing portions of Section 10 are not applicable — BMD has no host genetic architecture. This is a definitive negative finding, not a data gap.
  2. True incidence unknown: Seroprevalence quantifies exposure, not clinical incidence. Underdiagnosis is likely because BMD is non-specific and overlaps clinically/geographically with Lyme disease.
  3. Sex ratio and age distribution of clinical cases are not well quantified across populations.
  4. Diagnostic sensitivity limits: Acute serology is insensitive (16%); PCR requires active spirochetemia; standardized commercial assays remain limited.
  5. CNS disease is under-characterized — reported almost exclusively in small case reports of immunocompromised patients; natural history and optimal CNS treatment duration are not established from trials.
  6. No randomized treatment trials: Doxycycline efficacy rests on case series and relapsing-fever precedent, not RCTs; optimal regimen/duration is empirically derived.
  7. QoL and long-term outcomes are inferred from "no chronic sequelae" observations rather than prospective cohorts.
  8. Vaccine and prophylaxis research is essentially absent.

Proposed Follow-up Experiments / Actions

  1. Prospective incidence study in high-endemicity regions using paired acute/convalescent PCR + GlpQ serology to convert seroprevalence into true clinical incidence and define age/sex distributions.
  2. Structural and functional dissection of CbiA (AlphaFold model + Factor H co-crystal) to map the FH-binding interface and evaluate CbiA as a vaccine/therapeutic target; test cbiA knockout attenuation in the SCID vs immunocompetent mouse model.
  3. Longitudinal Vmp repertoire sequencing during human/murine infection to quantify switching rate, cassette usage hierarchy, and correlation with relapse timing.
  4. Randomized/pragmatic treatment comparison (doxycycline duration; ceftriaxone for CNS disease) to establish evidence-based regimens, including Jarisch–Herxheimer incidence.
  5. Improved point-of-care diagnostics: multiplex PCR panels and next-generation serologic arrays (GlpQ + Vmp + flagellin) validated against paired sera; evaluate metagenomic sequencing for CNS disease.
  6. Immunocompromised-host registry (especially rituximab-treated patients) to characterize CNS disease natural history, treatment response, and outcomes.
  7. Vector/reservoir surveillance integration (ArboNET Tick Module expansion) to map acarological risk and guide clinician awareness where B. miyamotoi and B. burgdorferi co-occur.
  8. Vaccine feasibility assessment targeting conserved surface antigens (CbiA, GlpQ), leveraging the observation that antibodies mediate clearance.

Report compiled from 9 confirmed findings and 35 reviewed papers across 5 investigative iterations. Evidence types: human clinical case series/cohorts, serosurveys, meta-analysis, in vitro microbiology, and mouse (including SCID) model studies.